Teaching Thinkers

A revolution in school reform – finally!

Austria’s new Education Minister Sonja Hammerschmid had barely taken office before she began ruffling feathers. The new “pilot” Comprehensive Schools and proposed centralized Education Directorate were not closed debates, she announced.  Nor were teachers’ qualifications, nor a school director’s right to hire and fire, nor….   It was quite a list.

Regional governments and teachers unions were not pleased.

“What’s needed is a new conception of teaching,” Hammerschmid told the Austrian daily Die Presse in early September. Not by changing what subjects are taught, she insisted, but how.

“We need to teach with a stronger focus on raising thematic questions.” she said, using the example of climate change, where a geographer might team-teach with a biologist and a physicist. This will be easier with more autonomous schools, one of the few reforms with nearly universal support.

But a lot of laws will also have to change – everything from the elimination of strict teaching unit-hours, to the school schedule and the integration of outside music and sports programs.

This is not going to be easy.

In Austria, education has long been a world of devils and details, with debates raging on the wisdom of routing  students through the Gymnasium (humanities) or Realschule (math and science) preparing for university, or the AHS (General High School) system, usually leading to vocational school. Other debates focus on extending the school day to accommodate working families, on inflexible national curricula, rigid teaching qualifications and distant school governance.

All of which is important, but not enough.

Putting thinking on the syllabus

Rarely does anyone talk about what’s happening inside these structures, what Austrian school students might be learning – which is, sadly, very little – about how to read intelligently, how to marshal an argument or defend an idea.  It is a pervasive failing I know from 15 years of teaching in Austrian universities.

Austrian schools don’t teach writing, nor do they teach critical thinking in any meaningful way, only correct spelling and grammar, the correct re-presentation of the course material. Original thought, ideas or insight are not on the syllabus.

Which is what makes Minister Hammerschmid’s approach so revolutionary, and so needed. What could be more important in the fog of fake news and electronic echo chambers that dominate public discourse?  What could matter more, when  – just when we need it most – we are losing out ability to think out of the box?

Midway through an Austrian Gymnasium, Dominique Veltz was sent by her bi-cultural parents to France to finish her schooling – her first experience of a French lycée.  For weeks, she wandered around in a state of shock.  The other students were writing essays, analyzing literature, arguing points of history. She had no idea where to begin. She was terrified.

“In an Austrian Gymnasium you were expected to learn a lot of material; in a French Lycée, you were expected to think!” said Veltz, who became a marketing executive with McCann.

It changed her life.

Dardis McNamee
Dardis McNamee is the Editor in Chief of Metropole. She has written for The New York Times, Conde Nast Traveler (NYC), the Wall Street Journal Europe and Die Zeit in Vienna, as well as having been a speechwriter to two U.S. ambassadors to Austria. She was awarded the 2007 Kemper Award for Excellence in Teaching (Media & Communications).

Help us help you

“Strong media and independent journalism are built on the shoulders of subscribers. Your support means the world to us.

Benjamin Wolf
COO & Managing Editor

The coronavirus outbreak affects and challenges your life in big and small ways. Metropole is here for you and we are proud to be your news source during this crisis.

But just as the coronavirus has increased the need for independent journalism, it has also undercut a major revenue source of media companies, ours included – advertising.

We need your support to keep it up – donate or subscribe and #helpushelpyou!

Support Metropole!


RECENT Articles

Coronavirus in Austria & Vienna | Vienna Introduces Gastrolist

The coronavirus has arrived in Austria. Here’s all you need to know about current measures, including where to get help, information and tips – updated regularly.

Torches on the Hill – Ultra-Conservatives March on the Kahlenberg

The Kahlenberg Church stands where an allied army gathered at dawn September 12, 1683 before sweeping down from the hills to break the Turkish siege of Vienna. Today it is both a cause for celebration and a rallying point for dubious arch-conservative fringe groups.

In Safety and Freedom, Romanian Entrepreneurs Found Success in Vienna

Romanians’ entrepreneurial spirit, long suppressed under the communist regime, is experiencing a renaissance – it can be felt even in Vienna.

SALONFÄHIG – Austrian Vintages That Hold Their Own Anywhere

The annual Wine Salon in Palais Coburg presented a tough jury's selection of the best of the current year. The setting was magnificent, the wines too.

COVID in High Places: Star Director Robert Dornhelm Tests Positive After VIP Eve...

“Freud” director Marvin Kren steps in for leading Austrian filmmaker, who remains ill following an Aug 18 diagnosis and an elite reception at Grafenegg.

The Out of Control Fringes

At a protest against coronavirus restrictions in Vienna, far-right extremists put on a homophobic display in front of a cheering crowd, while drawing outrage from the Greens.


Join over 5,000 Metropolitans, who already get monthly news updates and event invitations.