Free Lunch Society Documentary Makes a Case for Unconditional Basic Income

No Such Thing? The Free Lunch Society begs to differ.

Receiving public funds simply for existing may seem like sci-fi, but the idea of an unconditional basic income has been gathering steam, culminating last year in a much-touted referendum in Switzerland. Though soundly rejected by the Swiss, there’s an argument for it solving everything from government waste to income inequality to the decline of the family and other societal ills. Free Lunch Society, a new Austro-German documentary attempts to address all objections.

Acknowledging the issue’s utopian image, the film opens with scenes from Star Trek: The Next Generation, discussing a futuristic society where material needs no longer exist. Keeping it in layman’s terms is a double-edged sword, as funding mechanisms are kept vague. And dissent regrettably doesn’t factor into the narrative – a missed opportunity, as some of the best points come from unlikely champions such as libertarian Charles Murray.

Free Lunch Society
© The Golden Girls

The closest Free Lunch Society gets to a skeptic is yellow cab driver Sal Conte, a quintessential New Yorker who faces life with tough talk and cynicism mixed with unsinkable resilience. He offers views like “The strongest will be the leaders, the best will win and the rest will have to follow – simple economics” – his grim candor refreshing amid all the suffocating idealism.

The case for handouts

The Austrian filmmaker and economist Christian Tod builds his case in time-honored documentary style: panoramic establishing shots and interviews filmed squarely head-on, with voice-overs citing statistics and connecting to archival footage of inequality activists like Martin Luther King, Warren Buffett and Bernie Sanders.

The first notion to fall is that unconditional basic income is a leftist fancy; it has had supporters and detractors on both and all sides. Notably, economists Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman championed the idea as a transparent, unbureaucratic replacement for the welfare state.

Free Lunch Society

Exhibits include the Alaska Permanent Fund (the state has been reinvesting revenue from its oil windfall and paying dividends annually to permanent residents); other experiments were initiated in the U.S. under Lyndon Johnson and continued by Richard Nixon, supervised by a young ­Donald Rumsfeld. These and other trial runs in Germany, Canada and Namibia illustrate that a basic income has little impact on the willingness to work.

Former chairman of the Austrian lottery Friedrich Stickler confirms that most big winners don’t quit their day jobs but simply continue with less existential angst – and a few muster the courage to pursue hitherto unobtainable dreams. Several point out that freedom from financial dependency empowers citizens to more self-determination; Swiss activist Daniel Häni even considers it the next level of democracy. And as libertarian Charles Murray points out, capitalism already creates a myriad of social ills – how much worse can it get?

But Free Lunch Society saves its best argument for last: we may have no choice. As technology continues to advance exponentially, many blue- and white-collar occupations are disappearing without adequate replacements. Automation is making work as the foundation of the social contract increasingly unfeasible – but a post-labor society where we all realize our full potential all the more so.

Free Lunch Society

Fair shares for all?

In the end, Free Lunch Society makes a solid case, but the lack of dissenting opinions leaves it preaching to the choir. It summarizes talking points to the pleasure of proponents, but is unlikely to sway skeptics. Then again, maybe it will: Towards the end, cabbie Sal Conte returns, finally asked directly whether he would have done anything differently in his life if money weren’t an issue. He gets pensive, then admits that he would have liked to be a senator – “an honest senator, for a change.”

Nothing is stronger then an idea whose time has come. Whether that time is now remains to be seen.

 

Free Lunch Society

Starts May 5, Burg

Binu Starnegg
Manila born, Brooklyn bred and a longtime resident of Vienna, Binu Starnegg is currently managing editor for Metropole, where he completes myriad tasks with style and aplomb. Photo: Visual Hub

Help us help you

“Strong media and independent journalism are built on the shoulders of subscribers. Your support means the world to us.

Benjamin Wolf
COO & Managing Editor

The coronavirus outbreak affects and challenges your life in big and small ways. Metropole is here for you and we are proud to be your news source during this crisis.

But just as the coronavirus has increased the need for independent journalism, it has also undercut a major revenue source of media companies, ours included – advertising.

We need your support to keep it up – donate or subscribe and #helpushelpyou!

Support Metropole!


 

RECENT Articles

The Coronavirus in Austria & Vienna | New Support Platform Launched

Here’s all you need to know about current measures and developments, including trusted sources and tips – regularly updated.

Book Review | Daniel Kehlmann & The Power of Mockery

In Tyll, widely-acclaimed German-Austrian author Daniel Kehlmann reinvents a medieval legend to unmask the fatuity of rulers and the wisdom of tricks.

Why the EU Recovery Fund Is a Big Deal – for Europe & for the Climate

The recent budget-corona negotiations could lead to the creation of a fiscal union and a greater emphasis on sustainability.

Musical Chairs for UK-EU Expats – Grab a Seat Before the Music Stops

As the Brexit negotiations drag on, there is still no final clarity on the future of British citizens living in Europe. It is likely to be reciprocal – whatever that means. With Boris, who knows?

Max Schrems Challenges Facebook and Wins. Again.

European court ruling strikes down the transatlantic data transfer mechanism in a case initiated by the young Austrian data privacy advocate.

Vienna Takes on Airbnb Over Social Housing

After negotiations failed, the city is suing the short-term housing platform over illegal sublets in Gemeindebauten municipal apartments.
 

METROPOLE NEWSLETTER

Join over 5,000 Metropolitans, who already get monthly news updates and event invitations.