Growth and Its Discontents

Central Europe has experienced a soaring economy in the last two decades. Yet the disaffection of many shows the limits of what economic growth alone can achieve.

Central Europe is thriving as never before in history. Any macroeconomic indicator will tell you that. While the measures are imperfect, the Prague and Bratislava regions appear among the top ten richest in the EU by purchasing power per capita. While the eurozone struggles to reach growth over 1% per annum, in Central Europe 3% has become the norm.

But people are not happy. This discontent is transformed into growing number of votes going to populist, nationalist and extremist parties, which sometimes even play with the idea of leaving the EU altogether – gambling with the foundations of growth of the region.

It’s a paradox – which we must nonetheless try our best to explain.

The answer lies in a couple of layers hidden under the statistics. As always, the devil is in the details.

First, seeming prosperity is not shared by all, and in most cases not even by a majority of the people. And second, the easy comparison with the neighbors just across the (now open) border can breed discontent. Older people remember 30-year old promises that they would catch up quickly with the West in economic terms. For them, that means mostly Germany and, to a lesser extent, Austria.

When they go shopping in German supermarkets across the border, they find the same or similar products as in their countries, but cheaper and of better quality in the larger, more experienced consumer markets in the West. Many work there too, so they see salaries that are still the multiples of what they can earn at home. And they see the lower quality of public services and often education back home. So, the simple everyday comparison acts as a powerful anger generator, creating a feeling of second-class EU citizenship.

In the 1990s, countries like Poland, Czechia and Slovakia became the source countries of cheap labor for German and Austrian companies. In the early years of transformation, that was probably the only way to move forward in the transition from planned economies to a free market model.

But now, 30 years on, with a new generation who grew up in freedom and relative prosperity, not only older people but also many of the young see themselves stuck in a kind of vicious circle without the long-term prospects they now expect: They are the best-educated generation ever, but they cannot get salaried employment, save money or get a mortgage to buy a house.

All this played a crucial role in Poland in 2015, when conservative nationalists from the Law and Justice party (PiS) attracted more young voters than any other, skillfully exploiting these grievances on the social networks where they live and where other – liberal and pro-European – parties failed.

People simply feel that they do not have a share in the success that politicians praise on television.

Bailiffs at the door

Then there are also idiosyncratic reasons country to country, like the foreclosure phenomenon in the Czech Republic. Here, a bad law, the greed of special interests and the inability of justice to respond, there are an estimated 800,000 to 900,000 people – a tenth of the population of 10 million – who are buried in debt and live under threat of the bailiffs coming to repossess property in default. In Czechia, people can easily fall in this trap by borrowing from nonbanking lenders luring them with exotic holidays or pretty presents for Christmas, or paying off the fine for fare-dodging on public transport.

Financial illiteracy combined with the prevailing official narrative of success has created a mass of indebted people who live on the edge without any hope for change. In the last round of elections, the greatest gains for nationalists and populists were in regions with the highest number of people living in fear of the bailiffs.

So, economic growth is one thing, but the lack of functioning judiciary (to enforce contracts) and regulatory institutions that work, combined with low salaries and few prospects for improvement is something else. So far, these are issues politicians have been unable to address. Instead, they offer the politics of identity, praising a “glorious past” instead of building toward a prosperous future.

Central Europe, then, stepped into the trap of old-fashioned liberalism, i.e. the idea that economic growth alone will automatically improve every aspect of life, including democratic standards, and that prosperity will be shared easily by all. That dream has vanished with the crisis of 2008-2009, when institutions and politicians failed to address the real causes of the crisis and left people alone to fend for themselves.

Growth itself cannot bring prosperity and a functioning liberal democracy, that is the lesson of Central Europe of the last 30 years. Unfortunately.

Martin Ehl
Chief International Editor of the Czech economic daily Hospodářské noviny and a syndicated columnist writing on Central European issues.


You like local independent journalism in English? So do we!

To keep providing you with current news, insights, opinion and Schmäh about our shared hometown, we need your help.
We chose to provide our daily coverage for free, because we believe in equal access to information. And we want to be independent from our advertisers, so we can deliver the news that you want. With your help, we can keep giving you the open, independent journalism you deserve.

Don’t let the advertisers win!


If you’re able, please support Metropole today from as little as €1
or choose an amount:

Previous articleEurope’s Essence
Next articlePro & Con | March 2019

RECENT Articles

3 Ways to Swear Like a Real Wiener

Entire books have been written about the ingenious ways the Viennese swear, rant, yammer and nag. And we know how to help you get acquainted with the high art of Viennese swearing.

The Burgtheater’s (im)Perfect Crib

Real time surtitles in German and English now make it possible for non-German speakers and the hard of hearing to enjoy Vienna’s greatest stage. But maybe you don’t need them.

5 Things You Didn’t Know About Empress Elisabeth “Sissi” of Austria

Better known by her nickname “Sissi,” she has captured the hearts of the public ever since she was immortalized by actress Romy Schneider in a trilogy of 1950s romantic comedies.

Donald Tusk’s Clear Voice

Welcoming to Scotland, the perennial European is not about to leave the political stage.

“Mein Fall” | Austrian Writer Tells of Sexual Abuse

As a choirboy at the Zwettl Monastery in the 1960s, novelist Josef Haslinger was regularly assaulted by his superiors. Now he wrote about it.

Passing the Baton

The Vienna Theatre Project meditates on MLK’s last night on earth in Katori Hall’s “The Mountaintop.”

5 Anti-Valentine’s Day Movies | It’s Difficult to Love

If the most saccharine of holidays is starting to get to you, here are five sobering – some would say more realistic – portrayals of human emotion.

Keeping It Together

Ken Loach takes on the human cost of the gig economy in his latest film, "Sorry We Missed You".