Opinion | Europe’s Identity Under Crisis: Is Populism the Answer?

The anguish over protectionism misses a deeper message about European identity

The news about Europe these days is discouraging: headlines, books and essays all tell a common story: “The Rebirth of Populism”; “How Far is Europe Swinging to the Right?” The End of Europe: Dictators, Demagogues and the Coming Dark Age. It makes pretty grim reading.

After several decades of mobility and mingling across fluid borders, we now find ourselves in retreat into refuges of protectionist politics. But it’s not economic. It’s about identity. Just when we need Europe more than ever, the continent seems to be breaking apart amid a continent-wide craving for a cultural home.

We shouldn’t be surprised, really. Europeans have always known that their differences matter. As in this joke from an EU website: How do you get Europeans to do things they don’t want to do? You tell the British it’s traditional, the French it’s fashionable, the Germans it’s an order and the Italians it’s forbidden! Okay, okay, but still…

Our cultures are who we are, a lens through which we see the world. So when European integration results in a blurring of identities, pretty soon, it starts to get personal. This can be dangerous: Many Austrians to this day are convinced that Marie Antoinette, daughter of Empress Maria Theresia, was simply misunderstood by the French. On being told the poor had no bread, her legendary retort “Let them eat cake!” was not unfeeling, they say, so much as classic Wiener Schmäh – using irony to transform an ugly reality into humor. Schmäh, they will explain, is not just a throwaway remark, it is a Weltanschauung, that things are not what they seem – they are worse, and all you can do is laugh it off. To the trained ear, it is an art form and a relief. If not, it can be a disaster. And without their cultural context, Europeans feel lost.

Ivan Krastev, political scientist and permanent fellow at the Institute for Human Sciences in Vienna, describes a kind of “demographic panic” among his fellow Bulgarians at the waves of refugees, whose arrival “signals their exit from history.” Who will be left “to read Bulgarian poetry in one hundred years?” In Vienna’s boulevard press, a mother in St. Pölten complains that her son is one of only three Austrians in his Volksschulklasse, while pensioners in Hernals walk through their neighborhoods with eyes averted, saying they no longer feel at home.

We must be careful not to dismiss these complaints. Instead, we should listen, even applaud, this clear sense of identity; the voices of EU member cultures knowing who they are and thinking it matters. Cultural protectionism is, in this sense, the essence of Europe. It always was, it always should be. When we think about it, Europe really is all about our differences as the essential background for what we share.

Dardis McNamee
Dardis McNamee is the Editor in Chief of Metropole. She has written for The New York Times, Conde Nast Traveler (NYC), the Wall Street Journal Europe and Die Zeit in Vienna, as well as having been a speechwriter to two U.S. ambassadors to Austria. She was awarded the 2007 Kemper Award for Excellence in Teaching (Media & Communications).

Help us help you

“Strong media and independent journalism are built on the shoulders of subscribers. Your support means the world to us.

Benjamin Wolf
COO & Managing Editor

The coronavirus outbreak affects and challenges your life in big and small ways. Metropole is here for you and we are proud to be your news source during this crisis.

But just as the coronavirus has increased the need for independent journalism, it has also undercut a major revenue source of media companies, ours included – advertising.

We need your support to keep it up – donate or subscribe and #helpushelpyou!

Support Metropole!


RECENT Articles

Coronavirus in Austria & Vienna | Rapid Antigen Tests Available as of Tomor...

The coronavirus has arrived in Austria. Here’s all you need to know about current measures, including where to get help, information and tips – updated regularly.

Facing the Closed-Door Topic of Migrants and Sexual Assault

While most crime is down, alarming increases in violence against women, often by recent migrants, increases the pressure on efforts to support successful integration.

Black Voices – ‘Writing History’ in Austria

Following the popular Black Lives Matter protest in Vienna, young activists launched a Citizens’ Initiative demanding a national action plan against racism.

Vienna Election – The Greens Call for Unity as the SPÖ Weighs its Options

The mayor’s delegation will meet with all the parties before formal coalition negotiations begin on October 26.

Meet Mary Larunsi, an Austrian Fashion Model With Nigerian Roots

“What you see in the pictures is not necessarily the reality. I don’t get flown anywhere in a private jet with a glass of champagne in my hand. In the end, it’s hard work.”

Vienna Has Voted – The Final Results in Detail

Viennese voters have handed the ruling SPÖ of Mayor Michael Ludwig a decisive victory. All other parties win a higher vote share. Only the far-right-wing FPÖ implodes, losing more than three quarters of its voters.


Join over 5,000 Metropolitans, who already get monthly news updates and event invitations.